When Green REALLY isn't Green (no building content)

So I have a confession to make - and you may see a few of these from me as I take steps to lessen my own carbon footprint.

As horrible as I am at it (I'm not even being modest--anyone who has played with me will agree), I really enjoy the game of golf. But I've been having a more and more difficult time finding it to be the relaxing experience it is supposed to be as I am becoming more conscious about the environmental impacts. With each golf course ranging from 75-150 acres (and they've been increasing in size apparently as improvements in equipment have allowed people to hit the ball further distances-- note I seem to be the exception to this "benefit"), you can see how the effects of water usage and land consumption could really add up. The ecosystem of Palm Springs, for example, has totally changed over the years due to all of the courses and artificial humidity, and has had a notable effect on water flows in the Colorado River from whence a lot of the required water comes.

I was pleased to discover that there are some efforts underway to get courses to be more environmentally friendly, however. Borrowing from Wikipedia: "The modern golf course superintendent is often trained in the uses of these [more environmentally sound] practices and grasses. This has led to some mitigation in the amount of chemicals and water used on courses. The turf on golf courses is an excellent filter for water and has been used in many communities to cleanse grey water, such as incorporation of bioswales." The USGA website talks about environmental impacts of golf, though they seem to still be in the research stages (and have been since 1991....)

I recall taking a walk on a golf course with my father many years ago-- he used the setting to explain the concepts of Permaculture which is a something I've been fascinated by ever since and I still have a goal of learning more about it. He constructed an image in which fish would be raised in the water hazards. And instead of mowing lawns, cattle would graze the fairways, reducing the need for electric mowers, and simultaneously alleviating the need to grow crops to raise the animals. The way I play, we'd probably need to put helmets on the cattle which would introduce a footprint of its own, but that would probably be a lesser evil.

Some of these concepts have actually been deployed in certain parts of the world-- notably in New Zealand, where Permaculture is strong and "it is not uncommon for rural courses to have greens fenced off and sheep graze the fairways." And there is apparently a sport called Extreme Golf -- I can't tell whether this is concept or reality yet, but "the extreme golf course features un-mowed meadows and forest instead of fairways, with "goals" scored on temporary greens (a circle 20 feet in diameter)."

I haven't heard of any sustainable courses in the US yet, but I'll be keeping an eye out for them, and I plan to start asking about what sustainable practices are in place when I visit different courses.


JohnCommoner www.futurehousen

JohnCommoner

www.futurehousenow.com

Max, I didn't know you were a golfer! Me too, big time. Oh, do I love the game. But your post echoes a lot of thoughts I've had about golf and the environmental impact of increasingly large, heavily fertilized courses. The game is going in the wrong direction from its Scottish roots. I think that if it doesn't change it will someday be gone, because the truth is in an overpopulated world of the not-too-distant future, the amount of land and energy it takes to play golf will eventually kill the game.

But there is hope. Have you read Geoff Shackelford? He's a fantastic writer and a great proponent of putting the game back on track. His books are wonderful, I've pretty much read them all. Though he mostly writes non-fiction, his best book (in my opinion) is The Good Doctor Returns, a novel that also tells the story of better golf on better courses, golf like you'd probably like to see. He's got a great website too: www.geoffshackelford.com. Check it out, you'll like it.

Also, check out Oakhurst Links (www.oakhurstlinks.com). It's America's first course. Golf there is still played with hickory shafted clubs, the course is appropriately short, and sheep roam freely. We need more courses like that!


courses

It seems like it would be a dream job for a course designer to try to do one that meets some of these challenges. And did you see that BGTV member Permaculture may be designing a course? 

I'm enjoying one of my other favorite things this week which is fly fishing. Like golf, it's a great lesson in patience and perseverence, key things I try to bring back with me to  the real world.

- maxmsf


I agree 100%

I can confirm that Maxmsf is really bad at golf. He's pretty good at driving the cart however.


Speaking of Golf...

Thought you may want to check this out... I seem to come across the right things at the right moments.

http://www.beyondpesticides.org/golf/principles/index.htm

Stacey Champion, CIE
Owner/Consultant
Champion Indoors, LLC/Champion Indoor Env. Services, LLC

"Dedicated to the mission of assisting in the creation of healthier indoor environments."